Advertising Disclosure
Our rankings are cleverly generated from the algorithmic analysis of thousands of customer reviews about products, brands, merchant’s customer service levels, popularity trends, and more. The rankings reflect our opinion and should be a good starting point for shopping. By purchasing the products we rank, you’ll get the lowest price we found while we may receive a commission at no cost to you, which will help us continue to provide you with value.
Best Choice Rawlings 
Rawlings Sporting Goods Player Preferred Fist Base Mitts, Brown, Size 12.5, Left Hand Made of the highest quality materialsMizuno 
Mizuno GXF102 Youth Prospect First Baseman Mitt, 12.5-Inch, Right Hand Throw Patent pending heel flex technology increases flexibility and closureRawlings 
Rawlings | Foundation First Base Mitt | Right Hand Throw | 12.5" - Single-Post Double-Bar Web | Black/Grey AMAZON EXCLUSIVE RAWLINGS X AARON JUDGE COLLAB | For every FOUNDATION Series glove purchased, Rawlings and Amazon will dBest Value Franklin Sports 
Franklin Sports Baseball First Baseman's Mitt- Adult + Youth Baseball Right Handed Fielding Glove - CTZ5000 Righty Cowhi EASY BREAK IN: The soft synthetic leather material is lightweight and responsive making the glove easy and quick to breaRawlings 
Rawlings Liberty Advanced 13In 1St Base Softball Mitt LH Single-post reinforced, double bar web forms a snug, secure pocket for first base mittsGP (ジーピー) 
GP 53702 Baseball Glove First Mitt 1st Baseman Soft Grass Baseball Catchball Black Right Throw Glove Release Year/Model Year: 2020EvoShield 
EvoShield X-Srz Party Animals Limited Edition Sliding Mitt White/Pink Adult Protective mitt straps onto the baserunner's handRawlings Rawlings | Sandlot Baseball First Base Glove | Right Hand Throw | 12.5" - Modified Pro H-Web 12.5 in. FIRST BASE MITT, MODIFIED PRO H WEBMizuno Mizuno GXF50FP MVP Prime Fastpitch Softball First Base Mitts, 13", Right Hand Throw, Worn on Left Hand, Black Bio soft leather: professional style smooth leather that has the perfect balance of oil and softness for exceptional feeWILSON WILSON 2023 A2000® SCM1DSS 33.5” Baseball Catcher’s Mitt - Right Hand Throw Wilson 2023 A2000 SCM1DSS 33.5” Baseball Catcher’s Mitt - Right Hand ThrowMACGREGOR MacGregor Pro 100 1st Base Mitt LHT (EA) MacGregor 12.5" 1st Base MittMizuno Mizuno GXF50PB4 MVP Prime Baseball First Base Mitt 12.5", 1st Base, Right Hand Throw Bio Soft Leather: Professional style smooth leather that has the perfect balance of oil and softness for exceptional feeWILSON Wilson Fall 2024 A1000® 1620 12.5” Baseball First Base Mitt - Saddle Tan/Blonde/White, Left Hand Throw Wilson Fall 2024 A1000 1620 12.5” Baseball First Base Mitt - Saddle Tan/Blonde/White, Left Hand ThrowWILSON Wilson 2024 Baseball Classics Series A2000 1679 12.5” Baseball First Base Mitt - Right Hand Throw, Blonde/Black Wilson 2024 Baseball Classics Series A2000 1679 12.5” Baseball First Base Mitt - Right Hand Throw, Blonde/Blackハイゴールド(Hi-GOLD) HI-Gold RKG-111F Camel LH Shonen Soft Mitt ROOKIES Series First Mitt for Right Throw First Baseman Material: (Surface) TR steer leather (back) co-leatherRawlings Rawlings | R9 Baseball First Base Mitt | 12.5" |Modified Pro H Web | Left Hand Throw DESIGNED FOR SELECT YOUTH BASEBALL PLAYERS | Ages 8-14ハイゴールド(Hi-GOLD) HI-Gold High Gold Boys Soft First Baseman Mitt ROOKIES Series RKG-811F Black LH Right Throw First Mitt Body Color: BlackWILSON WILSON Sporting Goods 2019 A2000 FP1B SuperSkin First Base Fastpitch Mitt - Left Hand Throw Black/Vegas Gold/White Super Wilson A2000 FP1B SuperSkin 12" First Base Fastpitch Mittnorespnea norespnea Baseball Sliding Mitt, Sliding Mitt for Baseball and Softball, Baseball Sliding Mitt for Youth and Adult，Baseb Upgraded Protection Baseball Sliding Mitt: The top and bottom of the sliding mitt are designed with high impact resistanRawlings Rawlings | Renegade Baseball First Base Glove | Left Hand Throw | 12.5" - Single Post Double Bar Web Deep, flexible pocket is ideal for Baseball or SoftballRawlings Rawlings | Protective Sliding Mitt | Adult & Youth Sizes | Black/White THREE-PIECE DESIGN | Featuring neoprene, TPE, and an asymmetrically flexible Monoflex carbon fiber plate for elite perfozett ZETT BJFB71513S Boys Soft Baseball First Mitt, Zero One Stage, for First Baseman, Pastel Brown (3200), Right Throw Material: Natural leather (Surface: Steer leather, Flat back: Steer leather)ハイゴールド(Hi-GOLD) HI-Gold RKG-131F High Gold Boys Soft Mitt, ROOKIES Series, Black, LH, Right Throw, First Baseman, First Mitt Material: (Surface) TR steer leather (back) co-leatherzett ZETT BJFB71513S Boys Soft Baseball First Mitt, Zero One Stage, for First Baseman, Black (1900), Right Throw Material: Natural leather (Surface: Steer leather, Flat back: Steer leather)zett ZETT BJFB71413S Boys Baseball First Mitt, Zero One Stage, for First Baseman, Right Throw Made of natural leather (front / steer leather, flat back / steer leather)WILSON WILSON 2024 A1000 1620 12.5” Fastpitch Softball First Base Mitt - Black/White/Silver, Left Hand Throw Wilson 2024 A1000 1620 12.5” Fastpitch Softball First Base Mitt - Black/White/Silver, Left Hand ThrowWILSON Wilson Spring 2025 A2K® 1679SS 12.5” Baseball First Base Mitt - Right Hand Throw, Black/Teal Wilson Spring 2025 A2K 1679SS 12.5” Baseball First Base Mitt - Right Hand Throw, Black/TealSSK(エスエスケイ) SSK SPF 130 Hard Type Special Selection Mitt Series, for First Baseman, Camel x Tan (1247), L (Right Throw) Genuine Leatherハイゴールド(Hi-GOLD) Basic Customer BSG165FL Softball Soft Mitt for First Base Black x R Orange LH Right Throw Material: Front: Basic custom steer leather, flat back / basic soft leather HG silicone label: gold label cannot be replFranklin Sports Franklin Sport MLB Baseball + Softball Sliding Mitt - CFX PRT Youth Protective Baserunning Sliding Glove - Left + Right PROTECTIVE: The CFX PRT sliding mitts are designed to help runners protect their hands and fingers from jams and sprainsハイゴールド(Hi-GOLD) HI-Gold OKG-610F SR Dark Brown RH Grab, General Soft Grab, First Baseman, First Mitt Material: TR steer leather (flat back) co-leatherzett ZETT BJFB70513N Boys Soft Baseball First Mitt, Neo Status VL, for First Baseman, Pastel Brown (3200), for Right Throw Material: Natural leather (outer surface: RG leather, flat back: RG leather)Rawlings Rawlings | Shutout Fastpitch Softball Glove | RHT | 13' | First Base Mitt | Black/White Designed for First baseman this 13 inch faspitch first base mitt with single post double bar web design provides everythMizuno Mizuno 312453.F887.09.1250 Franchise GXF90B2 First Base Mittens, Coffee Cork Pre-oiled tumbled leather that is game ready and long lasting. Hilo lacing: alternating lace pattern retains the integriWILSON Wilson 2024 A2000 1620 12.5” Fastpitch First Base Mitt - Right Hand Throw, Black/Grey/Red Wilson 2024 A2000 1620 12.5” Fastpitch First Base Mitt - Right Hand Throw, Black/Grey/Red; Pro Stock Leather: Pro StockSSK(エスエスケイ) SSK WNSF1324 Softball Winddream First Baseman Made of natural leatherzett ZETT BRFB30233 Pro Status Soft Baseball First Mitt, for First Baseman, Right Throw Made of natural leather (Surface: Pro status R leather, flat back: Prostate R leather)WILSON Wilson Spring 2025 A2000® 1677 12.5” Baseball First Base Mitt - Left Hand Throw, Blonde/Red/Sky Blue Wilson Spring 2025 A2000 1677 12.5” Baseball First Base Mitt - Left Hand Throw, Blonde/Red/Sky Bluezett ZETT BRFB33413R Soft Baseball First Mitt, Winning Road, for First Baseman, Right Throw Made of natural leather (front / steer leather, flat back / day steer)Franklin Sports Franklin Sport MLB Baseball + Softball Sliding Mitt - CFX PRT Adult Protective Baserunning Sliding Glove - Left + Right PROTECTIVE: The CFX PRT sliding mitts are designed to help runners protect their hands and fingers from jams and sprainsSSK(エスエスケイ) SSK SPF 130 Hard Type Special Selection Mitt Series, for First Baseman, Light Tan x Tan (4547), L (Right Throw) Genuine LeatherSSK(エスエスケイ) SSK AJSSF1324 Soft Pro Edge Advanced First Baseman Made of natural leatherRawlings Rawlings | Select PRO LITE Youth Baseball Glove | Right Hand Throw | Kris Bryant | 11.5" 11 1 by 2 inch all leather youth baseball glove styled after Kris Bryant's game modelXanax Baseball Xanax Mitt, First Mitt, Xanax Limited Hard, Spectus, for First Baseman, BHF3502 DR Orange x Tan (DR2027), R (Ri Hard First Mittハイゴールド(Hi-GOLD) HI-Gold MKG-302F High Gold Hard and Soft All-Around Mitt Gray x Orange LH Right Throw First Baseman Material: (Surface) TY16 steer leather (flat back) co-leatherzett ZETT BJFB70413N Boys Baseball First Mitt, Neo Status, for First Baseman, for Right Throwing Made of natural leather (outer surface: RG leather, flat back: RG leather)ハイゴールド(Hi-GOLD) Basic Customer BSG865FR Softball Soft Mitt for First Base Navy x Camel RH Left Throw Material: Front: Basic custom steer leather, flat back: basic soft leather, HG label: black base x aluminum gold x rim nzett ZETT BJFB71413S Boys Baseball First Mitt, Zero One Stage, for First Baseman, Right Throw Made of natural leather (front / steer leather, flat back / steer leather)Mizuno Mizuno GFN1150B5 Franchise BB | Infielder Baseball Glove | 11.5" | Center Pocket Design | Deep 3 Web Full Grain Leather Shell & Laced Binding: Premium quality design with great durability.WILSON Wilson WBW102361 Pro Staff Baseball Glove for Hardware, Made in Japan, for First Baseman, Black Position/Target Audience: First Base/Right Throwハイゴールド(Hi-GOLD) Basic Customer BSG265FL Softball Soft Mitt for First Base R Orange x Black LH Right Throw Material: Front: Basic custom steer leather, flat back / basic soft leather, HG silicone label: silver, label cannot bezett ZETT BPROFM230S First-Base Baseball First Mitt, for First Baseman, for Right Throws, Pastel Brown Made of natural leather (front / J steer leather, flat back / J-steer leather)zett ZETT BJFB70513N Boys Soft Baseball First Mitt, Neo Status VL, for First Baseman, Black (1900), Right Throw Material: Natural leather (outer surface: RG leather, flat back: RG leather)WILSON Wilson 2024 Fastpitch Classics Series A2000 1620FPSS 12.5” Fastpitch First Base Mitt - Left Hand Throw, White/Coal Wilson 2024 Fastpitch Classics Series A2000 1620FPSS 12.5” Fastpitch First Base Mitt - Left Hand Throw, White/Coalzett ZETT BRFB30333 Pro Status Soft Baseball First Mitt, for First Baseman, Right Throw Made of natural leather (Surface: Pro status R leather, flat back: Prostate R leather)BROLEO Sliding Mitt, Baseball Sliding Mitt for Right Hand, Youth and Adult Size, Baseball Softball Sliding Glove for Hand Prote HAND PROTECTION: It features hardened exteriors on both the top and bottom, providing protection to hand when sliding inSSK(エスエスケイ) SSK ANSSF3324 Soft Pro Edge Advanced First Baseman Made of natural leatherハイゴールド(Hi-GOLD) HI-Gold SKG-350F SKG-350F High Gold Limited Mitt for General Hardware, LH, Right Throw, for First Baseman, Catcher Mitt, Material: (Surface) TR steer leather (flat back) co-leatherWILSON Wilson Fall 2024 A2K® 1679 12.5” Baseball First Base Mitt - Right Hand Throw, Red/Blonde Wilson Fall 2024 A2K 1679 12.5” Baseball First Base Mitt - Right Hand Throw, Red/Blondeハイゴールド(Hi-GOLD) HI-Gold SKG-300F Camel LH Limited Mitt for General Hardware, First Baseman, Limited Edition Material: (Surface) TR steer leather (flat back) co-leatherzett ZETT GRAFECT BJFA70213 Boys Soft Grab, for First Baseman, D Orange, LH Material: Natural leather / (surface) steer leather, (flat back) day wearSSK(エスエスケイ) SSK SPF 130 Hard Type Special Selection Mitt Series, for First Baseman, Camel x Tan (1247), R (Left Throw) Genuine Leatherハイゴールド(Hi-GOLD) Basic Customer BSG965FR Softball Soft Mitt for First Base Black x R Orange RH Left Throw Material: Front: Basic custom steer leather, flat back / basic soft leather, HG label: black base x aluminum gold x redzett ZETT BRFB30333 Pro Status Soft Baseball First Mitt, for First Baseman, Right Throw Made of natural leather (Surface: Pro status R leather, flat back: Prostate R leather)Mizuno Mizuno Pro GMP2-300FBM First Base Mitts, Tan US kip leather: tighter fibers creating more durability and a premium, soft feel for top of the line performance you canハイゴールド(Hi-GOLD) HI-Gold OKG-710F SR Lemon Yellow LH Mitt for General Soft-Type First-Baseman Right Throw Material: TR steer leather (flat back) co-leatherMizuno Mizuno GPSF-30 Pro Select FP | Premium First Base Mitt Fastpitch Glove | 12.5" | H Web Gender Engineered: Mizuno's engineering philosophy to maximize performance by tailoring products to meet the needs of thFranklin Sports Franklin Sports Baseball and Softball Glove - Field Master - Baseball and Softball Mitt, Tan, 12.5" Right Hand Throw EASY BREAK IN: The soft synthetic leather material is lightweight and responsive making the glove easy and quick to breazett Zett BRFB30533 Soft Baseball First Mitt, Prostatus, for First Baseman, Bordeaux Brown (4000), Right Throw Material: Natural leather (Surface: Pro status R leather, flat back: Pro state R leather)zett ZETT BRFB30333 Soft Baseball First Mitt, Prostatus, for First Baseman, Bordeaux Brown (4000), Right Throw Material: Natural leather (Surface: Pro status R leather, flat back: Pro state R leather)SSK(エスエスケイ) SSK SPF 130 Solid Special Selection Mitt Series for First Baseman, Orange x Tan (3547), R (Left Throw) Genuine Leatherzett Zett BRFB30233 Soft Baseball First Mitt, Prostatus, for First Baseman, Bordeaux Brown (4000), Right Throw Material: Natural leather (Surface: Pro status R leather, flat back: Pro state R leather)SSK(エスエスケイ) SSK SPF 130 Hard Type Special Selection Mitt Series, for First Baseman, Light Tan x Tan (4547), R (Left Throw) Genuine Leatherzett Zett BPROFM533 Hard Baseball First Mitt, Prostatus, for First Baseman, Black (1900), Right Throw Material: Natural leather (front / domestic cow leather, flat back / domestic cow leather)SSK SSK SPF 130 Hard Type Special Selection Mitt Series, for First Baseman, Reddish Brown x Tan (4847), R (Left Throw) Genuine Leatherzett Zett BPROFM333 Hard Baseball First Mitt, Prostatus, for First Baseman, Brown (3700), for Right Throwing Material: Natural leather (front / domestic cow leather, flat back / domestic cow leather)zett Zett BPROFM533 Hard Baseball First Mitt, Prostatus, for First Baseman, Orange (5600), Right Throw Material: Natural leather (front / domestic cow leather, flat back / domestic cow leather)SSK SSK AJSSF1324 Soft Pro Edge Advanced First Baseman Made of natural leatherzett Zett BPROFM533 Hard Baseball First Mitt, Prostatus, for First Baseman, Brown (3700), for Right Throwing Material: Natural leather (front / domestic cow leather, flat back / domestic cow leather)zett Zett BPROFM233S Hard Baseball First Mitt, Prostatus, for First Baseman, Black (1900), for Right Throwing Material: Made of natural leather (Surface: Prostate leather, Flat back: Prostate leather)zett Zett BRFB333S Soft Baseball First Mitt Prostate SE First Baseman, Pastel Brown (3200) Right Throw Material: Natural leather (front / domestic cow R leather, flat back / domestic cow R leather)zett ZETT BPF143 PROSTATUS Hard Mitt, for First Baseman, Orange, LH (for Right Throwing) Material: Natural leather / (surface) smooth kip leather, (flat back) smooth kip leatherzett ZETT BPROFM233S Hard Baseball First Mitt, Prostatus, for First Baseman, Oak Brown (3600), for Right Throwing Material: Made of natural leather (Surface: Prostate leather, Flat back: Prostate leather)Safety 1st Safety 1st No Scratch Mittens Pink 2Pk Mittens help prevent babies from accidentally scratching themselves whilst they sleepzett Zett BPROFM533 Hard Baseball First Mitt, Prostatus, for First Baseman, Bordeaux Brown (4000), Right Throw Material: Natural leather (front / domestic cow leather, flat back / domestic cow leather)zett ZETT BPROFM233S Hard Baseball First Mitt, Prostatus, for First Baseman, Deep Orange (5800), for Right Throwing Material: Made of natural leather (Surface: Prostate leather, Flat back: Prostate leather)zett Zett BPROFM233S Hard Baseball First Mitt, Prostatus, for First Baseman, Pastel Brown (3200), for Right Throw Material: Made of natural leather (Surface: Prostate leather, Flat back: Prostate leather)zett ZETT BPROFMP53 Hard Baseball First Mitt, Prostatus, for First Baseman, Black x Oak Brown (1936), Right Throw Material: Made of natural leather (Surface: Pro state premium leather, flat back: Pro state premium leather)zett ZETT BPROFMP53 Hard Baseball First Mitt, Prostatus, for First Baseman, Brown x Oak Brown (3736), for Right Throw Material: Made of natural leather (Surface: Pro state premium leather, flat back: Pro state premium leather)ハイゴールド(Hi-GOLD) HI-Gold WKG-F10 Hardboard Mitt, Technique, First Baseman, Natural Yellow X Black, Right Throw (LH) Size: 11.8 inches (30 cm). *8.3 inches (21 cm)zett Zett BPROFM233S Hard Baseball First Mitt, Prostatus, for First Baseman, Night Black x Pastel Brown (1932N), for Right Th Material: Made of natural leather (Surface: Prostate leather, Flat back: Prostate leather)zett ZETT BPROFMP53 Hard Baseball First Mitt, Prostatus, for First Baseman, Pastel Brown x Oak Brown (3236), for Right Throw Material: Made of natural leather (Surface: Pro state premium leather, flat back: Pro state premium leather)zett ZETT BRFB33413R Soft Baseball Glove Winning Road Series for First Baseman, Left Throw, Black x Pastel Brown (1932) Color: Black x pastel brownハイゴールド(Hi-GOLD) HI-Gold SKG-250F High Gold General Hard Mitt, Brown x Camel, for First Baseman, RH, Left Throw, First Mitt, Medium Size, Material: (Surface) TR steer leather (flat back) co-leatherzett Zett BPFB12413N Hard Baseball First Mitt, Neo Status VL, For First Baseman, Black x Oak Brown (1936), For Right Throwing Material: Natural leather (Surface: Steer leather, Flat back: Steer leather)ハイゴールド(Hi-GOLD) HI-Gold MKG-202F High Gold Hard Soft All Target First Mitt, True Pole, Dark Red x Tan, for First Baseman, Right Throw LH Material (Surface) TY16 steer leather (flat back) co-leatherハイゴールド(Hi-GOLD) HI-GOLD (high gold) baseball mitt Kokorokyoku Wagyu SERIES (Wagyu series) Glove first baseman Winning back Brown × black 素材:平裏/共革ハイゴールド(Hi-GOLD) HI-Gold MKG-203F High Gold Hard Soft All Target First Mitt, True Pole, Dark Green x Beige, for First Baseman, Right Thro Material (Surface) TY16 steer leather (flat back) co-leatherHESTRA Hestra Gloves 36921 My First Basic Mitt, Light Red - 2 Material: polyesterzett ZETT BPFB12423 Neo Status First-Baseman Hard Grab, Right Throw, Black Material: Made of natural leather, outer / G leather, flat back / G leather